« Shadowbrook | Main | Eating Democracy »

October 30, 2005

Us or Them? Neither, thank you.

Us conservatives living in blue states all know people who "won't date Republicans" or are proud of the fact that they have no Republican friends. Thomas Sowell discusses this phenomenon and provides some historical context for these views in his latest syndicated column:

. . . Back during the 1930s, in the years leading up to World War II, one of the fashionable self-indulgences of the left in Britain was to argue that the British should disarm "as an example to others" in order to serve the interests of peace.

When economist Roy Harrod asked one of his friends whether she thought that disarming Britain would cause Hitler to disarm, her reply was: "Oh, Roy, have you lost all your idealism?"

In other words, it was not really about which policy would produce what results. It was about personal identification with lofty goals and kindred souls.

The ostensible goal of peace was window-dressing. Ultimately it was not a question whether arming or disarming Britain was more likely to deter Hitler. It was a question of which policy would best establish the moral superiority of the anointed and solidify their identification with one another.

"Peace" movements are not judged by the empirical test of how often they actually produce peace or how often their disarmament tempts an aggressor into war. It is not an empirical question. It is an article of faith and a badge of identity.

October 30, 2005 at 09:51 AM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83422d96553ef00d835219e7b53ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Us or Them? Neither, thank you.:

Comments

The comments to this entry are closed.